The Dallas Cowboys’ biggest weakness on the offensive side of the football is most obviously the tight end group. The wide receiver group is second, but it’s a distant second to the uncertainty and inexperience at the tight end position currently.

Even before Jason Witten up and retired, the Cowboys weren’t in great shape — mostly because of age-related decline — but they had a reliable starter who could give them 50-60 snaps a game and could contribute on third downs and in the red zone.

The future Hall of Famer is gone to the Monday Night Football booth on ESPN, leaving an Armageddon-sized crater behind. Gone are 87 targets, 63 catches, 560 yards, and most importantly five touchdown receptions from 2017.

Trying to be the next man up to fill the void are Geoff Swaim, Blake Jarwin, Dalton Schultz, and Rico Gathers. Combined, they have nine catches for 94 yards and zero touchdowns in the NFL (all from the Swaim Train).

As we try to project who might take the lead role among this tight end group, as opposed to looking for one guy to take 90% of the snaps at the position like Witten might, we should probably look at this as a rotational deployment.

Or a Tight End by Committee. 

Let’s look at how each guy could be deployed based on potential formations that the Dallas Cowboys like to use.

Geoff Swaim

Geoff Swaim will be in the game when the Dallas Cowboys go with two and three tight end formations. He’s got the most experience and Jason Garrett likes to use the guys he knows. Geoff Swaim will get the first shot at running with the first team as the veteran player of the group.

At the moment, Swaim is the most well-rounded of the bunch. A reliable tight end who has caught passes in meaningful games for the team, even if it isn’t a lot of them. While experience isn’t everything, it matters when looking at players who are going to get playing time.

Swaim might not have the highest upside in the group, but he’s a trusted and reliable player.

Blake Jarwin

The Dallas Cowboys signed Tight End Blake Jarwin to the practice squad as an undrafted free agent in 2017.

The Cowboys front office was so high on him that they activated him from the practice squad toward the end of the 2017 season to make sure he wasn’t signed by the Philadelphia Eagles.

He’s a player who could fill a “move tight end” role on the team, using him in 11 and 12 personnel packages as a big slot receiver in certain matchups. Dak Prescott has gone on record about the team wanting to utilize more “run-pass options” (or RPOs) this season, and Jarwin’s size and receiving ability immediately make him a threat.

I could see them using Swaim as the in-line tight end and then splitting Jarwin out wide to take advantage of linebacker matchups the team likes.

He can be a threat down the seam and in the middle of the field that Witten hasn’t been in a couple of years because of the aforementioned age-related decline.

The Cowboys have always done a good job finding and developing undrafted free agents and when Bryan Broaddus from DallasCowboys.com was asked who could be the next great undrafted free agent, he had Jarwin on his mind.

“The way that the coaching staff was using Blake Jarwin tells me that they’re expecting big things from him. He has been splitting snaps with Geoff Swaim throughout these practices for the starting tight end spot, so he’s going to have a chance to grow.”

Bryan Broaddus – DallasCowboys.com

Dalton Schultz

Dalton Schultz is probably the most intriguing of the prospects. He was an impact player for the Stanford Cardinal and running back Bryce Love as they racked up more than 2,000 yards rushing in 2017.

His opportunities as a pass catcher were limited, but he flashed some tools that show he has the ability to be a solid receiving tight end in the NFL.

At the moment, he’s probably the second tight end in the game when the team goes to two and three tight end formations.

Typically, tight ends struggle to adapt to the NFL in their rookie seasons because they aren’t often asked to block as much. Schultz already comes with a bit of that pedigree.

The challenges for him will be learning the nuances of an NFL playbook as well as his responsibilities in the passing game.

Rico Gathers

The most hyped of all the tight ends for the Dallas Cowboys is Tight End Rico Gathers.

In the 2017 preseason, he flashed a ton of potential in the passing game, showing off his hands and athleticism as he caught a couple of touchdown passes. After he suffered a concussion, he was placed on IR for most of the season and really didn’t get another shot. He comes into camp with a lot to prove, mostly that he can be a reliable option for the team on the 53-man roster.

He’s still super raw and has more to learn in the blocking aspect of the game, and the team is taking a tough love approach to Rico in hopes that they can motivate him to earn a larger role than what he’s looking at right now.

While we are all intrigued by the prospect of Gathers in the passing game, he’s on the outside looking in at the moment for a team that may not be able to keep four tight ends.

Like Jarwin, as it stands now, Gathers’ best role would be in passing situations in 11 personnel (one running back and three tight ends) or as a move tight end lined up in the slot to take advantage of linebacker or safety mismatches.

He has the athleticism to beat linebackers and the size to box out defensive backs, and as fans of the team, we should hope that he earns a role on this squad because they definitely could use his size and athleticism in the red zone. But I wouldn’t hold my breath on it.

✭ ✭ ✭ ✭ ✭

According to reports, the tight ends that have been ahead of the pack in OTAs and minicamps have been Blake Jarwin and Geoff Swaim. Training camp is a whole different ball game, though, as the team will put pads on and the competition will heighten.

Over the next couple months we’ll find out if one of these tight ends rises to the top, or if a committee approach is in store for the Dallas Cowboys in 2018.